Here's what i've done so far ( which is not nearly enough to get a clear picture of what's going on in the story ), but I gotta get it out here.
I remember I did the first thumb and it looked so repulsively Conceptart that I tried to steer away from that with the rest. As a result they all have issues. But I kind of liked the one in the center.
And I present to you a truly disappointing Captain Hook. Yes, it's that bad.
Some attempts at children ensued.
And thumbs of Peter Pan, who is a girl for some reason.
And so we have a winner.